New York Tenant Screening Laws: A Landlord Compliance Guide
Fee Cap · Deposit Limit · Source of Income · Fair Chance for Housing · Eviction Records · Fair Housing
Screening a rental applicant in New York is one of the most heavily regulated things a landlord does. Overlapping federal, state, and New York City rules cap what you may charge, limit how you may use credit, criminal, and eviction history, and protect classes of applicants that federal law leaves out. This is a compliance overview for landlords: what New York and New York City permit, what they forbid, and where the traps are. It is not legal advice, and New York housing law moves fast — treat every figure and rule below as a starting point to verify against the current statute and with a New York landlord-tenant attorney before you act.
This guide stays in its lane. It covers the compliance rules that govern screening in New York specifically — fees, deposits, source of income, criminal history, eviction records, and protected classes. For the general mechanics of evaluating an applicant — reading a credit report, verifying income, checking references — see our guide on how to screen tenants. For New York’s eviction procedure and the just-cause regime, see the New York eviction process and the New York good-cause eviction law. For the broader state overview, see our New York tenant screening laws hub.
The short video below frames the New York compliance picture; the sections that follow break down each rule — the application-fee cap and the mandatory waiver, the deposit limit, source-of-income protection statewide and in New York City, the criminal-history limits under the NYC Fair Chance for Housing Act and statewide fair-chance principles, the eviction-record blacklist restriction, credit checks and consent, and the fair-housing classes New York adds.
New York tenant screening rules at a glance
- A New York landlord may not charge any application fee except for a background or credit check, capped at the lesser of actual cost or twenty dollars, and may collect it only after giving the applicant a copy of the check and the screening company’s receipt (N.Y. Real Prop. Law § 238-a(1)). See the New York application fee guide.
- New York has no statewide reusable-report rule, but the landlord must waive the check fee when the applicant provides a background or credit check conducted within the past thirty days (N.Y. Real Prop. Law § 238-a(1)(b)).
- New York State has no statewide fair-chance housing statute. In New York City, the Fair Chance for Housing Act (Local Law 24 of 2024, in force since January 1, 2025) allows a criminal check only after a conditional offer, limits it to the sex-offender registry and to misdemeanor convictions within three years and felony convictions within five years of sentencing or release, and requires five business days for the applicant to respond (N.Y.C. Local Law 24 of 2024).
- Lawful source of income, including housing vouchers, is a protected class statewide (N.Y. Exec. Law § 296(5)).
- A landlord may not refuse to rent because an applicant was involved in a past or pending landlord-tenant action, and the Attorney General may seek a civil penalty of five hundred to one thousand dollars per violation (N.Y. Real Prop. Law § 227-f).
- The federal Fair Credit Reporting Act is the baseline: an adverse action based on a consumer report requires the notice in 15 U.S.C. § 1681m(a).
New York Screening Compliance at a Glance
Screening Fee
Capped at cost, up to twenty dollars
Security Deposit
One month’s rent maximum
Source of Income
Protected class — accept vouchers
Criminal History
Sharply limited in NYC
Why New York Screening Is Different
In most of the country a landlord may charge a modest application fee, run a standard credit and criminal check, and decline anyone who does not clear the bar, subject only to the federal Fair Housing Act and the Fair Credit Reporting Act. New York layers several more regimes on top of that baseline, and New York City adds still more. The practical result: a screening process that is perfectly lawful in, say, Texas or Florida can expose a New York landlord to civil penalties, a discrimination complaint, or a private lawsuit.
Three bodies of law do most of the work. First, the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019 (HSTPA) — a sweeping statute that, among many other changes, capped application fees and security deposits and restricted the use of eviction-court records. Second, the New York State Human Rights Law, amended in 2019 to make lawful source of income a protected class statewide. Third, in the five boroughs, the New York City Human Rights Law and the city’s Fair Chance for Housing Act, which add further protections and sharply limit criminal-history screening. Federal law — the Fair Housing Act and the FCRA — still applies underneath all of it.
A Note on Currency and Sourcing
The statutes described here have been amended repeatedly since 2019, and New York City’s criminal-history rule is recent enough that its application is still developing. We cite each law by name so you can look it up, and we flag the points that are most likely to have changed or to be contested. Nothing here substitutes for reading the current statute and getting advice from a New York landlord-tenant attorney about your specific property and situation.
Takeaway
New York screening runs on three overlapping regimes — the HSTPA, the state and city Human Rights Laws, and the NYC Fair Chance for Housing Act — on top of federal law. A screening step that is routine elsewhere can be unlawful here. Verify each rule against the current statute before you build it into your process.
The Application-Fee Cap and the Mandatory Waiver
The rule New York landlords hit first is the cap on what you may charge to screen an applicant. Under the HSTPA (the fee provision is commonly cited as Real Property Law section 238-a), a landlord or broker generally may charge an applicant no more than the actual cost of the background or credit check, and in any event no more than twenty dollars — whichever is less. Verify the current amount before relying on it; New York has revisited these figures, and the number can change.
Two things follow from that. The charge is a reimbursement, not a service fee — so you generally may not fold in your administrative time, processing effort, or any profit margin. And charging even a modest amount above the true cost of the report, while still under the cap, can still violate the statute. If you collect the fee and run the check yourself, the law also generally requires you to give the applicant a copy of the report and a receipt or invoice from the screening company.
The Mandatory Fee Waiver
The provision that most often trips up landlords is the waiver. New York law generally requires that if an applicant hands you a copy of a background or credit check they had run within roughly the past thirty days, you must waive the background- and credit-check fee. A stale report does not trigger the waiver, and you can still evaluate the applicant on the merits — but you cannot charge the applicant for your own check when a qualifying report from the past thirty days is offered. Confirm the exact look-back window and any documentation requirements in the current statute.
A Compliant Alternative: Applicant-Paid Reports
Because the cap regulates only what the landlord may charge, one clean approach is to let applicants buy their own screening report directly from a consumer reporting agency and submit it with the application. When the applicant selects and pays the provider, and you do not collect, process, or mark up any fee, the cap is not triggered at all — and the applicant keeps ownership of their consumer data. This is a risk-management convenience, not a way around the waiver or the fair-housing rules.
Takeaway
In New York the screening fee is a reimbursement capped at cost, up to twenty dollars, and you generally must waive it entirely when the applicant supplies a recent qualifying report. Never bundle in administrative time or profit. Verify the current figure and window before you set your process.
The One-Month Security-Deposit Limit
Screening decisions and deposit decisions are linked, so the deposit rule belongs here. Under the HSTPA, a New York landlord generally may not collect a security deposit — or advance — greater than one month’s rent, regardless of the applicant’s credit score or perceived risk. You cannot condition approval on a larger deposit for an applicant you consider marginal, because the extra deposit itself is unlawful, and demanding it from some applicants and not others can look like discrimination.
The same statute added tighter rules on how a deposit must be held and returned, including a walkthrough right and a deadline to itemize and return the balance after move-out. Those return mechanics are beyond the scope of a screening guide, but the headline for screening is simple: a weaker applicant does not entitle you to a bigger deposit in New York. Verify the current deposit rules, including any narrow exceptions, before relying on them.
Takeaway
New York generally caps the security deposit at one month’s rent. You cannot demand a larger deposit from an applicant you view as higher-risk — the larger deposit is itself unlawful and can invite a discrimination claim. Verify the current rule and any exceptions.
Source-of-Income Protection: You Must Consider Vouchers
This is the rule most likely to catch an out-of-state owner off guard. In 2019 New York amended the State Human Rights Law (the change is often called the Lawful Source of Income Non-Discrimination Act, amending Executive Law sections 292 and 296) to make lawful source of income a protected class statewide. New York City’s Human Rights Law contains a parallel protection. In practice, a landlord generally may not refuse an applicant, or hold them to a stricter standard, because part of the rent will be paid with a housing voucher or another lawful subsidy.
Protected lawful sources of income are read broadly and generally include Section 8 and other federal, state, and local housing assistance, Social Security and Supplemental Security Income, disability benefits, veterans’ benefits, child support, and alimony, among others. The core compliance duty is consistency: you must apply your income standard the same way to every applicant and may not, for example, impose a higher income-to-rent multiple on a voucher holder or advertise “no vouchers.”
An Area of Active Litigation — Verify Before Relying
The source-of-income protection has been the subject of ongoing litigation, and at least one court decision has questioned how the state provision is applied in some circumstances. The protection remains a serious compliance obligation, but its precise reach is contested and moving. Do not treat this section as settled — verify the current state of the law and get advice from a New York attorney before adopting any policy that touches voucher applicants.
How the Income Standard Interacts With Vouchers
A common trap is applying an income-to-rent multiple — say requiring income of forty times the monthly rent — to the full rent for a voucher holder whose out-of-pocket share is a fraction of that. Guidance has generally treated applying such a multiple to the full contract rent, rather than the tenant’s actual share, as a form of source-of-income discrimination. Confirm the current guidance and consider counsel before using any income multiple with subsidized applicants.
Takeaway
In New York, lawful source of income is a protected class statewide and in New York City — you generally cannot reject or disfavor an applicant for paying with a Section 8 voucher or other subsidy, and must apply your income standard consistently. This area is being litigated, so verify current law and consult counsel.
Criminal History: The NYC Fair Chance for Housing Act
Criminal-history screening is where New York City departs most sharply from ordinary practice. The Fair Chance for Housing Act (enacted as Local Law 24 of 2024) rewrote the rules for how covered housing providers in the five boroughs may use criminal records. Our research indicates it took effect on or about January 1, 2025; confirm the effective date and the current text, because implementation details were still settling when this was written.
The core structure, as we understand it, resembles the “fair chance” approach used in employment: you generally evaluate the applicant on everything except criminal history first, and you may run a criminal check only after making a conditional offer of housing. When you do look, the law limits what is even reviewable — commonly described as roughly a five-year look-back for felony convictions and roughly a three-year look-back for misdemeanor convictions (measured from release or sentencing), with certain registrable sex-offense obligations treated separately. Non-convictions — arrests that did not lead to a conviction, sealed cases, and expunged or vacated records — generally may not be considered at all. Verify these periods against the current law before applying them.
The Individualized-Assessment and Notice Steps
Under the city law, if you intend to pull back a conditional offer because of reviewable criminal history, you generally must give the applicant the records you relied on, allow a set period — commonly described as around five business days — to respond with corrections or mitigating information, perform an individualized assessment weighing the offense against safety and tenancy, and provide a written explanation of the decision. Skipping any of these steps is where liability arises. Confirm the exact procedure and timing in the current rule.
Statewide Fair-Chance Principles
Outside New York City, there is no single statute as detailed as the city’s Fair Chance for Housing Act, but the general direction of New York law disfavors blanket criminal exclusions. The individualized-assessment approach reflected in New York’s Correction Law Article 23-A — long applied to employment and licensing decisions — and federal disparate-impact liability under 24 CFR 100.500 both point landlords statewide toward case-by-case evaluation rather than automatic bars. A flat “no felonies” policy anywhere in New York is legally risky. Verify how these principles apply to housing in your jurisdiction before relying on them. Our overview of criminal history in tenant screening covers the general compliance framework.
Takeaway
In New York City, criminal history generally may be checked only after a conditional offer, is limited to a short look-back for convictions, excludes non-convictions, and requires an individualized assessment with notice before denial. Statewide, avoid blanket criminal bars. This law is new — verify the current rule and get counsel.
Eviction Records and the Tenant-Blacklist Problem
New York also restricts using an applicant’s history in housing court. Under the HSTPA (the blacklist provision is commonly cited as Real Property Law section 227-f), a landlord may not refuse to rent to an applicant on the basis that they were involved in a past or pending landlord-tenant action, and a denial that follows a check of landlord-tenant court records or a tenant-screening “blacklist” built from those records is presumed to violate the statute unless the landlord rebuts it. Enforcement has been described as carrying civil penalties per violation, pursued by the state Attorney General. Verify the current penalty range and the exact scope of the restriction.
The reason is practical: a great many housing-court cases are filed by landlords and never reflect any tenant wrongdoing — a case may be dismissed, settled, or filed in error, yet still surface in a commercial screening database as an “eviction.” New York’s response is to bar denials based on an applicant’s involvement in a landlord-tenant action. New York has also moved to seal or limit access to certain eviction-court records, which further constrains what a screening report can lawfully surface and how you may use it. If an eviction record appears, the applicant’s involvement in that case cannot be the basis for declining them.
Screening-Vendor Data Is Not a Safe Harbor
Buying a report from a tenant-screening company does not shift the compliance risk off the landlord. If you decline an applicant based on eviction-court data the vendor surfaced, the denial is still yours to defend, and the FCRA’s adverse-action duties still apply. Verify what your screening vendor is reporting for New York applicants and whether it is lawful to act on it.
Takeaway
New York bars denying an applicant because they were involved in a past or pending landlord-tenant action, and has moved to seal certain records. A past housing-court case is not a lawful basis for a decline. Verify the current statute and penalties, and remember the vendor’s data does not insulate you.
Credit Checks, Consent, and the FCRA
The New York fee and waiver rules sit on top of the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act, which still governs how you obtain and use a consumer report. Before you pull an applicant’s credit or background report, the FCRA requires a permissible purpose. Screening companies also require the applicant’s signed written authorization for a report that includes credit — documented and kept on file.
If you then decline the applicant, raise the deposit, or add a condition because of something in the report, that is an adverse action, and the FCRA generally requires an adverse-action notice: the reason, the name and contact information of the reporting agency, a statement that the agency did not make the decision, and the applicant’s right to a free copy of the report and to dispute it. New York’s own consistency and source-of-income rules apply alongside these federal duties. See our guides on adverse-action notices for landlords and screening best practices, and the fillable New York adverse-action notice.
Takeaway
Get standalone written consent before pulling any report, and send a proper adverse-action notice whenever the report drives a denial, a higher deposit, or a condition. The FCRA applies on top of every New York rule. Verify the current FCRA requirements and pair them with New York’s consistency duties.
Fair-Housing Classes New York Adds
The federal Fair Housing Act protects seven classes: race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status, and disability. New York protects those and adds several more, so a screening decision that clears federal law can still violate state or city law.
| Protected Class | Federal FHA | New York State / NYC |
|---|---|---|
| Race, color, national origin, religion, sex | Yes | Yes |
| Familial status, disability | Yes | Yes |
| Lawful source of income (vouchers, benefits) | No | Yes — statewide and NYC |
| Age | No | Yes |
| Marital status | No | Yes |
| Sexual orientation, gender identity or expression | Limited | Yes |
| Military / veteran status, and more (esp. in NYC) | Varies | Yes — NYC adds several |
The table is a compliance map, not the statute — New York City’s Human Rights Law in particular protects additional categories (such as certain immigration and citizenship-status considerations and lawful-occupation protections) and is enforced aggressively. The practical rule for screening: build one consistent, written set of criteria, apply it identically to every applicant, and document the reason for every decision. Verify the full, current list of protected classes for your jurisdiction before finalizing any policy.
Takeaway
New York protects more classes than federal law — adding lawful source of income, age, marital status, and more, with New York City adding still more. A decision that is fine under the federal FHA can violate state or city law. Screen every applicant against one consistent written standard, and verify the current protected-class list.
A Compliant New York Screening Workflow
Putting the rules together, a defensible New York screening process runs in a fixed order — the same for every applicant, documented at each step. Treat this as a framework to adapt with counsel, not a template guaranteed to fit your property.
Publish consistent written criteria
Set your income standard, credit threshold, and other criteria in writing, and apply them identically to every applicant. Do not advertise or imply that vouchers are unwelcome.
Charge the fee lawfully — or waive it
Collect at most the actual report cost, up to twenty dollars, and waive the fee when the applicant supplies a background or credit check from the past thirty days. Provide the report copy and receipt if you run the check.
Get the applicant’s signed authorization
Obtain the applicant’s signed authorization before pulling a report that includes credit, and keep it on file.
Evaluate income consistently, honoring vouchers
Apply your income standard to the applicant’s actual share when a lawful subsidy covers part of the rent, and never impose a stricter bar on voucher holders.
Handle criminal history last and lawfully
In New York City, defer any criminal check until after a conditional offer, limit it to reviewable convictions, exclude non-convictions, and run an individualized assessment. Statewide, avoid blanket bars.
Treat eviction records as a question, not a verdict
Do not deny because of a housing-court record or blacklist entry; Real Property Law section 227-f bars refusing an applicant on that basis.
Document the decision and send required notices
Record the reason for approval or denial, cap any deposit at one month’s rent, and send an FCRA adverse-action notice whenever the report drives a negative decision.
✓ Compliant Habits
- One written standard applied to every applicant
- Fee capped at cost, waived for recent applicant reports
- Vouchers and lawful subsidies accepted and evaluated fairly
- Criminal check deferred and individualized in NYC
- Adverse-action notice sent on every report-driven denial
✕ Practices That Invite Liability
- “No vouchers” ads or higher bars for subsidy holders
- Screening fee marked up above the report cost
- Deposit raised for “risky” applicants past one month
- Blanket criminal or eviction-record exclusions
- Denials with no documented reason or notice
None of this replaces legal advice. New York’s rules interact in ways that depend on your building, your location within the state, and the applicant’s circumstances — verify the current statutes and have a New York landlord-tenant attorney review your screening policy before you rely on it.
Screen New York Applicants the Compliant Way
Run credit, criminal, and eviction history through a process built for FCRA and New York fair-housing compliance — consistent criteria, proper consent, and the documentation that protects you.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much can a New York landlord charge to screen a rental applicant?
Under the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019, a New York landlord may charge an applicant no more than the actual cost of the background or credit check, capped at twenty dollars — whichever is less. The charge is a reimbursement, not a service fee, so it may not include administrative time, processing, or profit. This is a statewide rule. Verify the current amount and any local variation before you rely on it, because these figures change.
Must a New York landlord waive the screening fee if the applicant supplies their own report?
Generally yes. New York law provides that if an applicant gives the landlord a copy of a background or credit check completed within roughly the past thirty days, the landlord must waive the background- and credit-check fee. Confirm the exact window and requirements in the current statute, because the details can shift.
Can a New York landlord reject an applicant who pays with a Section 8 voucher?
No. New York State’s Human Rights Law makes lawful source of income a protected class statewide, and New York City’s Human Rights Law does the same, so a landlord generally cannot refuse an applicant, or apply a stricter standard, because they will pay part of the rent with a Section 8 voucher or another lawful subsidy. This is an area of active litigation, so verify the current state of the law and consult counsel.
What are the New York City rules on screening criminal history?
New York City’s Fair Chance for Housing Act (Local Law 24 of 2024), which our research indicates took effect on or about January 1, 2025, sharply limits how covered housing providers may use criminal history: they generally must evaluate the applicant on other criteria first, run any criminal check only after a conditional offer, look back only a limited number of years for most convictions, and perform an individualized assessment before denying. The exact look-back periods and covered-provider definitions are technical and were still being applied when this was written — verify the current rule and get legal advice before using criminal history in NYC.
Can a New York landlord deny an applicant for a past eviction case?
Be very careful. The Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act restricts denying an applicant based on their appearance in landlord-tenant court records, and many housing-court filings never reflect tenant fault. Relying on a tenant-screening blacklist of eviction filings is a recognized source of liability. Verify the current statute and consult counsel before using eviction-court data to decline an applicant.
Is the New York security deposit limited during screening?
Yes. New York generally caps the security deposit at one month’s rent, and you cannot demand a larger deposit from an applicant you view as higher-risk — the larger deposit is itself unlawful and can look like discrimination. Verify the current rule and any narrow exceptions before relying on it.
Does New York protect more applicants than the federal Fair Housing Act?
Yes. Beyond the federal classes — race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status, and disability — New York adds lawful source of income, age, marital status, sexual orientation, gender identity, and more, with New York City protecting still further categories. A screening decision that clears federal law can violate state or city law. Verify the current protected-class list for your jurisdiction.
Do I still have to follow the FCRA when screening in New York?
Yes. The federal Fair Credit Reporting Act applies on top of every New York rule. Have a permissible purpose (and the standalone written consent screening companies require) before pulling any report, and send an adverse-action notice — with the reason, the reporting agency’s details, and the applicant’s dispute rights — whenever the report drives a denial, a higher deposit, or a condition. Verify the current FCRA requirements.
Ready to Screen Your Next New York Applicant?
Get comprehensive credit, criminal, and eviction reports through a compliant workflow — make confident, well-documented leasing decisions under New York and NYC law.
Related New York Guides
Published by Tenant Screening Background Check
Established 2004 · 20+ Years · All U.S. States & Territories · Statute-Based · Attorney-Reviewed
A Private Eye Reports™ service trusted by landlords, property managers, and attorneys.

