← Back to All States

🗽 New York Tenant Screening Laws (2025)

Complete guide to New York rental application fees, background check requirements, source of income protections, and Fair Housing compliance for landlords and tenants.

📋 Overview of New York Tenant Screening Laws

New York operates within the national patchwork of tenant screening laws by state that varies dramatically from state to state. Understanding New York’s specific requirements is essential for both landlords seeking compliance and tenants understanding their rights during the rental application process. This comprehensive guide covers all aspects of New York tenant screening law as of 2025.

The New York rental market serves approximately 19.3 million residents, with Approximately 46% of households rent – highest in nation. NYC dominant market with extreme competition.. Average rents in New York range from $3,000-$5,000+ in Manhattan; $2,000-$3,500 in outer boroughs; $1,500-$2,500 upstate, making tenant screening an important process for landlords protecting their investments and tenants seeking fair treatment in a competitive market. The NYC Housing Court; upstate: City/Town Courts handle summary proceedings in New York. For a deeper understanding of the legal framework, see our guide on landlord-tenant laws explained.

Key aspects of New York tenant screening law include:

• Application Fees: $20 maximum. Not required.
• Source of Income: Protected under state law – landlords cannot discriminate based on vouchers or public assistance
• Criminal Background: Fair Chance law limits how criminal history can be used
• Fair Housing: Federal protections plus state-added classes: Source of income, Sexual orientation, Gender identity or expression, Marital status, Military status, Age, Arrest record, Conviction record (with limits), Domestic violence victim status, Immigration or citizenship status (NYC)
• Enforcement: New York Division of Human Rights; NYC Commission on Human Rights
• Security Deposits: See New York security deposit laws for deposit limits and return requirements
• Eviction Process: Review New York eviction notice laws before starting any removal proceedings

📜 Key New York Statutes

• N.Y. Real Prop. Law § 220 et seq.
• N.Y. Exec. Law § 296 (Human Rights Law)
• HSTPA 2019
• NYC Local Law 24 (Fair Chance Housing)

💰 Application Fee Regulations in New York

New York provides clear protection for prospective tenants through its $20 application fee cap. This limit represents a balance between allowing landlords to recover legitimate screening costs while preventing excessive charges that can burden renters searching for housing in competitive markets. The cap applies regardless of the property’s rental price, location, or the landlord’s actual screening costs.

The $20 cap encompasses all charges related to the application process. Landlords cannot circumvent the cap by charging separate “processing fees,” “administrative fees,” or “credit check fees” in addition to the capped application fee. Any attempt to collect additional fees beyond the $20 maximum may violate state law and expose landlords to legal liability.

📋 What the $20 Cap Covers

• Credit Reports — Cost of pulling applicant’s credit history
• Background Checks — Criminal history and other background screening
• Eviction History — Searches for prior eviction records
• Reference Checks — Contacting previous landlords and employers
• Administrative Processing — Staff time reviewing applications
• Additional Fees — Cannot charge separate processing or service fees

Prospective tenants should ensure any fee charged does not exceed $20 and should request receipts documenting the fee payment. If a landlord attempts to charge more than the statutory maximum, tenants can file complaints with the appropriate state agency and may have grounds for legal action to recover excess charges.

🏛️ Source of Income Protections in New York

N.Y. Exec. Law § 296 prohibits discrimination based on lawful source of income. Statewide protection since 2019.

Source of income (SOI) protections represent a critical fair housing safeguard that New York has recognized at the state level. These protections ensure that tenants who pay their rent with income from sources other than traditional employment—such as housing vouchers, Social Security benefits, disability payments, child support, or retirement income—have equal access to housing opportunities. Without such protections, landlords could refuse qualified tenants simply because of how they receive their income, perpetuating housing discrimination and segregation.

The impact of SOI protections extends beyond individual tenants to entire communities. According to research from the Poverty & Race Research Action Council (PRRAC), approximately 66% of federal Housing Choice Voucher recipients are Black or Latino, 77% of voucher households are female-headed, and 26% include a family member with a disability. SOI discrimination therefore disproportionately affects communities already facing significant barriers to housing access.

🛡️ What’s Protected Under New York Law

• Housing Choice Vouchers (Section 8) — Federal rental assistance vouchers administered by local housing authorities
• VASH Vouchers — Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing vouchers for homeless veterans
• Social Security — Retirement and disability benefits from the Social Security Administration
• SSI/SSDI — Supplemental Security Income and Social Security Disability Insurance payments
• Child Support/Alimony — Court-ordered support payments
• Unemployment Benefits — State unemployment insurance payments
• Veterans Benefits — VA disability compensation and pension payments
• TANF/Public Assistance — Temporary Assistance for Needy Families and similar programs

🚫 Prohibited Landlord Conduct

Under New York’s source of income protections, landlords cannot engage in the following discriminatory practices:

• Outright Refusal — Cannot refuse to rent to applicants based on their income source
• Discriminatory Advertising — Cannot advertise “no Section 8” or “no vouchers” or similar exclusionary language
• Different Terms — Cannot offer different rental terms, conditions, or prices based on income source
• Discouragement — Cannot discourage applications from voucher holders or make process more difficult
• Steering — Cannot direct voucher holders to certain units or neighborhoods
• Pretextual Denial — Cannot use legitimate-sounding reasons to mask income source discrimination

🔍 Criminal Background Check Regulations in New York

NYC Fair Chance for Housing Act (Local Law 24) effective January 1, 2025. 5-year felony/3-year misdemeanor lookback limits.

Fair Chance housing laws represent an emerging area of tenant protection that recognizes the barriers to housing faced by millions of Americans with criminal records. In New York, these protections go beyond federal baseline requirements by establishing specific rules about when, what, and how criminal history can be considered in rental housing decisions.

🚦 Key Fair Chance Requirements

• Timing Restrictions — Criminal history inquiry may be delayed until after initial qualification screening
• Lookback Limitations — Older convictions beyond specified timeframes may not be considered
• Individualized Assessment — Must evaluate circumstances rather than applying blanket bans
• Written Explanation — Must provide specific reasons if denying based on criminal history
• Opportunity to Respond — Applicant may have right to explain circumstances or provide mitigation

⚖️ What Landlords Can and Cannot Consider

⚖️ Fair Housing Act Compliance in New York

All tenant screening practices in New York must comply with the federal Fair Housing Act, which prohibits discrimination based on race, color, religion, national origin, sex (including sexual orientation and gender identity as of 2021), familial status, and disability. Even facially neutral screening criteria can violate the FHA if they have an unjustified disparate impact on protected classes.

🏠 Federal Protected Classes

🏛️ Additional New York Protected Classes

Beyond the seven federal protected classes, New York law provides additional protections for the following characteristics:

These additional state-level protections expand the scope of fair housing law in New York beyond federal minimums. Landlords must ensure their tenant screening criteria do not discriminate against individuals in any protected class—federal or state—and that seemingly neutral policies do not have an unjustified disparate impact on protected groups.

📋 Screening Criteria Compliance

To ensure Fair Housing compliance in New York, landlords should:

• Document Criteria in Advance — Establish written, objective screening standards before advertising any unit
• Apply Consistently — Use identical criteria for every applicant for the same property
• Ensure Business Justification — Each criterion should serve a legitimate, non-discriminatory purpose
• Monitor for Disparate Impact — Regularly review whether criteria disproportionately exclude protected groups
• Consider Alternatives — If criteria has disparate impact, evaluate less discriminatory alternatives
• Accommodate Disabilities — Modify criteria when necessary as reasonable accommodation

🎯 Best Practices for New York Landlords

Successfully navigating New York’s tenant screening regulations requires landlords to implement consistent, documented processes that satisfy both federal requirements and any state-specific rules. The following best practices will help landlords make informed tenant selection decisions while minimizing legal risk and ensuring fair treatment of all applicants.

📋 Pre-Screening Preparation

• Establish Written Criteria — Before advertising any unit, document your objective screening standards including minimum income requirements (typically 2.5-3x monthly rent), credit score thresholds, rental history requirements, and any other objective factors you will consider
• Research Current Law — Verify current New York requirements as laws change. Check both state statutes and any applicable local ordinances in your municipality
• Prepare Disclosure Documents — Create written disclosures about application fees, screening criteria, and the application process to provide to prospective tenants before collecting any fees
• Select Compliant Screening Service — Choose a tenant screening provider that follows FCRA requirements and can provide adverse action notices as required

📝 Application Process

• Provide Written Information — Give applicants written disclosure of screening criteria, fee amount, and process before collecting applications or fees
• Obtain Written Consent — Secure applicant’s signed authorization before pulling credit reports or background checks as required by the FCRA
• Collect Proper Fees — Ensure any application fee complies with New York limits and is properly disclosed
• Apply Standards Consistently — Use identical criteria and process for every applicant to avoid discrimination claims

🔍 Evaluation Process

• Review Financial Qualifications — Verify income, employment, and ability to pay rent before considering other factors
• Check Rental History — Contact previous landlords to verify payment history and lease compliance
• Evaluate Credit Report — Review credit history in context, considering explanations for any issues
• Conduct Background Check — If permitted by timing rules, review criminal history with individualized assessment
• Document Decision — Record specific, objective reasons for approval or denial in writing

📤 Post-Decision Requirements

• Approval Notification — Promptly notify approved applicants and begin lease execution process
• Adverse Action Notice — If denying based on consumer report information, provide required FCRA notice identifying reporting agency and dispute rights
• Fee Handling — Process any required refunds of application fees per New York law
• Record Retention — Maintain application records, screening reports, and decision documentation for at least three years

👥 Tenant Rights in New York

Prospective tenants in New York have significant legal protections during the rental application process under federal fair housing law, the Fair Credit Reporting Act, and applicable state laws. Understanding these rights empowers applicants to identify illegal screening practices and seek recourse when discrimination occurs.

🛡️ Your Federal Rights During Screening

• Equal Treatment — Landlords must apply identical screening criteria to all applicants regardless of race, color, religion, national origin, sex, familial status, or disability
• Reasonable Accommodations — If you have a disability, landlords must make reasonable modifications to screening policies when necessary to provide equal housing opportunity
• Adverse Action Notice — If denied based on information in a consumer report (credit check, background check), you must receive written notice identifying the reporting agency and your dispute rights
• Free Credit Report — If denied based on credit report information, you’re entitled to a free copy from the reporting agency within 60 days
• Dispute Rights — You have the right to dispute inaccurate information in screening reports and have errors corrected within 30 days

📋 New York-Specific Rights

Beyond federal protections, New York law may provide additional rights during the tenant screening process:

• Application Fee Limits — $20 maximum
• Source of Income — Protected – landlords cannot discriminate based on lawful income source
• Criminal History — Fair Chance protections may limit when/how criminal history is considered
• Additional Protected Classes — Source of income, Sexual orientation, Gender identity or expression, Marital status, Military status, Age, Arrest record, Conviction record (with limits), Domestic violence victim status, Immigration or citizenship status (NYC)

🚨 Signs of Potential Discrimination

Be alert to these warning signs that may indicate discriminatory screening practices:

• Different Treatment — Being quoted different terms, prices, or requirements than other applicants
• Discouraging Comments — Landlord making comments suggesting the unit isn’t suitable for “people like you”
• Sudden Unavailability — Unit mysteriously becomes unavailable after landlord learns protected characteristic
• Excessive Requirements — Being asked for additional documentation or qualifications not required of others
• Steering — Being directed toward specific units or neighborhoods based on your characteristics
• Prohibited Questions — Being asked about national origin, religion, family plans, or disability

📞 What to Do If You Experience Discrimination

• Document Everything — Save all communications, advertisements, applications, and receipts. Record details of verbal interactions immediately
• Request Written Explanation — Ask for written reasons for any denial. Landlords may be required to provide this under FCRA
• File HUD Complaint — Contact HUD at 1-800-669-9777 or file online at hud.gov/fairhousing within one year
• Contact New York Division of Human Rights; NYC Commission on Human Rights — File state-level complaint for additional investigation and remedies
• Consult Attorney — Fair housing cases may be eligible for attorney fee recovery, making legal help accessible

📚 Related New York Landlord-Tenant Resources

For a complete understanding of New York rental law, explore these related guides:

📖 Landlord Guides & Tools

Maximize your screening effectiveness with these resources:

• Step-by-Step Screening — Follow our how to screen a tenant step-by-step for a proven process
• Best Practices — Review best practices for tenant screening for compliant screening
• New Landlords — Start with our first-time landlord screening guide for essential knowledge
• Eviction Prevention — Learn how eviction prevention through better screening saves time and money
• Rental Application — Download our free rental application template for immediate use
• Income Verification — Handle self-employed applicants with our guide on how to verify self-employed income
• Fraud Prevention — Protect yourself by learning how to spot fake pay stubs and how to spot fake landlord references

📊 New York Rental Market Context

Understanding the broader rental market context helps both landlords and tenants navigate tenant screening in New York. For landlords new to property management, our how to become a landlord provides essential guidance.

• Population: 19.3 million
• Rental Market: Approximately 46% of households rent – highest in nation. NYC dominant market with extreme competition.
• Average Rents: $3,000-$5,000+ in Manhattan; $2,000-$3,500 in outer boroughs; $1,500-$2,500 upstate
• Court System: NYC Housing Court; upstate: City/Town Courts handle summary proceedings
• Regional Comparison: Among most protective states nationally. More comprehensive than New Jersey, Connecticut, Pennsylvania.
• Eviction Costs: See the cost of eviction by state to understand potential expenses

🆕 Recent Developments in New York

NYC Fair Chance Housing Act (2025). HSTPA 2019 tenant protections. Ongoing strengthening.

NYC Fair Chance Housing Act (criminal history). NYC additional protected classes. Westchester, Nassau, other localities have strong enforcement.

Stay informed about changes by monitoring New York’s legislative updates and consulting our tenant screening laws by state for the latest information. Understanding rent increase laws by state is also important for property management planning.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions